Andy White Anthropology
  • Home
  • Fake Hercules Swords
  • Research Interests
    • Complexity Science
    • Prehistoric Social Networks
    • Eastern Woodlands Prehistory
    • Ancient Giants
  • Blog

Review of "Species with Amnesia" by Robert Sepehr

11/21/2016

 
Picture
"Dumpster fire" is surely one of the more over-used phrases of 2016. I'm going to throw some more garbage in and use it one more time:

Species with Amnesia by Robert Sepher (2015) is the literary equivalent of a dumpster fire.

My students and I read this book as part of the section on Ice Age Civilization in my Forbidden Archaeology class this semester. I chose the book because it checked the boxes for many of the issues that I wanted to address, and I could find no existing, detailed, online appraisal of it. As I read the book, I made of list of claims that I thought would be good for the students to evaluate (and I also found many instances of plagiarism without really trying). I ended up with far more topics than students, so I just picked some of Sepehr's bolder proclamations and handed them out. 

​It's hard to know where to even start with this thing, so we'll start at the very beginning (a very fine place to start).

Sepehr begins his 143-page attack on facts and logic by trying to discredit paleoanthropology and the study of human evolution. He has to, because his fantasy argument about an ancient super race of white Atlanteans depends on all that fossil evidence from Africa being grossly misinterpreted and the entire body of knowledge about human origins (except for outdated racist ideas about Cro-Magnon) being wrong. As discussed in this blog post, Sepehr focuses on the fraudulent Piltdown skull as evidence that science can get things wrong (duh) and then misunderstands the Lucy fossil and misrepresents Owen Lovejoy. To anyone familiar with the fossil evidence for hominin evolution, the first chapter is ridiculous.

And it only gets worse from there.

In the second chapter, Sepehr introduces the idea that "race" and "species" are equivalent and that human "races" are actually separate species. This isn't Sepehr's original thought, of course, but one handed down from the slavers and Nazis of the last centuries. Anticipating the argument that "species can't interbreed, therefore races are not species," Sepehr provides examples of inter-breeding among different animal species. He claims that it was race-mixing that diluted the superior genes of the Atlanteans and doomed their society.

Take a wild guess what "race" those Atlanteans were? A huge shock: they were tall, fair-haired, blue-eyed Aryans. Sepehr tries to link multiple exoduses from Atlantis to the succession of technological/chronological periods used to describe Upper Paleolithic Europe, focusing on the "Cro-Magnon" peoples of Europe as original emigres from Atlantis 40,000 years ago. Unsurprisingly, he describes Cro-Magnon as tall, fair-haired, blue-eyed people with high frequencies of RH- blood. None of those claims is supported by evidence. His identification of "Cro-Magnon" with "Nordic/Aryan" is not supported by any real data, and his assertions about the genetics of Cro-Magnon remaining unchanged for 28,000 contradicts things he says later in the book (about the evolution of blue eyes, for example, which only evolved 10,000-6,000 years ago).

Sepehr selectively uses an old literature to support his claim that Cro-Magnon spread into Europe from west to east, which is what one would expect if they came from a continent in the Atlantic. Modern data show, however, that the Aurignacian technology that was probably associated with the earliest anatomically modern humans in Europe actually spread from east to west, not west to east. The most recent Neanderthal remains are found in Iberia, consistent with modern human populations coming in from the other direction.

In order to try to make his Cro-Magnons more like what we'd expect "advanced" Atlanteans to be like, Sepehr attributes to them advanced astronomical knowledge (based on Paleolithic cave art). He also claims that Cro-Magnon peoples had agriculture, correctly noting (page 49) that "without agriculture, Atlantis, or any other antediluvian civilization, is no more than a myth."  He asserts that Cro-Magnon domesticated the horse, but the student who was assigned that topic didn't turn in his work. 

Sepehr blames rising sea levels at the end of the Ice Age for sinking Atlantis, stating that sea levels 400 feet lower would have exposed a large landmass in the middle of the Atlantic. Yeah, right. 

Sepehr attempts to identify traces of an advanced global culture run by white-skinned, blue-eyed people, tapping a lot of the usual suspects in the process. He goes over the familiar ground of misunderstanding Haplogroup X and advocating for the presence of Ice Age Europeans in the New World, wrongfully identifying indigenous Chilean peoples as having "Aryan" features, attributing the features of the Guanche of the Canary Islands to Atlantean heritage, and finding blue-eyed people in the New World and China.

And, of course, what ancient Aryan adventure would be complete without finding a few out-of-place swastikas around the world to tie the whole fantasy together.

And near the end, just to make sure the reader is thoroughly impressed by inconsistencies and lack of logic, he claims that Aryan Phoenicians brought agriculture to the New World in 1500 BC. 

But wait . . . didn't you say that the original refugees of Atlantis had agriculture in 40,000 BC? And that Atlanteans had colonized North and South America by the end of the Ice Age? Because they had blue eyes? And Haplogroup X?  But we know that the domestication of maize actually 

Oh never mind. Just light the whole thing on fire. 

It is fitting that the book ends with a typo:

"Whatever the cause of these periodic cataclysms on earth, it is clear is that there was a massive even that separates the Pleistocene (ice age) from our current Holocene age roughly 11,500 years ago. Rapidly melting ice caps caused a global rise in sea levels, submerging island and coastal communities world wide. Once we confront this, we may discover our historic cradle of civilization was never out-of-Africa, but out-of-Aftantis."
Weatherwax
11/21/2016 09:13:03 pm

Small correction. In paragraph 9 it should be: ...associated with the earliest anatomically modern humans in Europe actually spread from east to west, not west to east.

Andy White
11/22/2016 05:23:56 am

Thanks - fixed it.

Michael Re
5/9/2020 03:21:27 pm

You don’t think it’s real. Now his explanation of things may not be accurate. But there were past species of giants and other creatures. Go watch my videos then comeback and tell me we are the first intelligent species
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGjcR23GMUte0JTqcmqaX2w

Jason Torres
5/22/2020 02:25:42 pm

Allow me.. ahem...

WE ARE THE FIRST INTELLIGENT SPECIES...and not all of us are included in that "we".

Bob Jase
11/22/2016 09:39:12 am

The flood that destroyed Atlantis was like no other - it left clear completely contradictory that indicated it never happened.

Joe Mello
3/10/2020 01:05:08 pm

Not sure what your comments meant. It is alas unproven to have been real.

medsbluerose
6/3/2021 12:13:39 pm

Read Atlantis the Antidiluvian World and Ragnarok the age of fire and gravel. Both by Author and Statesman Ignatius Donnelly. All his books were written on acquired FACTS from the library of Congress oh dull one. Atlantis was indeed real and probable.

Only Me
11/22/2016 01:49:05 pm

How...why is this garbage allowed to be put in print? Atlantis wasn't real, which makes the version of history Sepehr's proposing fall apart. You can't use a myth to prove another myth!

Nick
1/18/2017 01:32:45 am

Troy was but a myth until a few years ago,.,

Inquirer
10/22/2017 04:20:22 am

Censorship is the answer to uncomfortable ideas, huh? Thanks for the input Einstein.

R D Duttine
3/28/2018 07:56:57 pm

"why is this garbage allowed to be put in to print?" Is this a serious and legitimate question? If so then I shall counter with this question - "why is anything you say allowed to be put in to print?"

You sir seriously know how to ruin a man's night! My dinner gets cold as I write this because I am compelled to respond immediately to some of your vitriol and subjective personal opinion which you most certainly extol as truth, fact, and undeniable logic.

Any person of any regard has the same rights here in America and as far as I am concerned these rights are God given if you will to the human race. You sir have it in your mindset that if you disagree with something which goes against your personal belief of factual and logical then it should not be "allowed" to be written. Who decides what can or cannot be posted? You? The "powers that be?" A panel?

You speak of facts as of everything we have been taught to be true and factual is written on stone and can never change!

Not so long ago it was a fact that the Earth was flat.

It was a fact that you could sail your boat off of the edge of the world.

It was fact that Bill Clinton did not have sexual relations with that woman.

Need I continue?

We get it. You don't like this book by Robert. Ok, fine. Pray tell what makes you so inclined to bash and write a most scathing and hateful review about this book when the only reasons that you've offered for such opinion is literally your own personal opinion not grounded in any logic but your own and without a single fact to counter Roberts theory?

Your logic and your choice of facts are purely subjective.

In closing I ask again in mockery of you - who allows this GARBAGE to be published? Are you a dictator like rocket man? #Disgust

Michael Vecsey
4/6/2019 03:41:32 pm

Lol.
The earth has been known to be round since the greeks. Clinton got a bj and did not have sex with monica. You seem to have misread this paper. I do similar topics in my college courses. The professor here is pointing out when robert s is utterly wrong. There may be a historical truth to platos story. But robert simply makes amateurish and hilarious mistakes regularly in his books and videos.

Chris
8/29/2020 06:18:42 pm

Well said R D Duttine, well said

David Barber
9/2/2020 01:10:22 pm

It was never a fact that the earth was flat, sorry but fisherman always knew it wasn't. By following birds to find fish and also sailing close to land is a dangerous endeavor in uncharted waters. Just another myth perpetuated by people like yourself who have read but not explored. That being said you do make some good points but I do agree that the author is a anti-semitic racist promoting Nazi propaganda

Brina
2/4/2021 08:11:54 am

Was that a reply/comment to the Writers review of the book: "Pray tell what makes you so inclined to bash and write a most scathing and hateful review about this book" OR the comment of the person who said: why is this garbage allowed to be put in print" LOL either way Good reply!

Marcus
4/25/2021 11:25:25 pm

I think what you meant to say was; "It was once believed by some that the earth was flat". It was never a fact, no matter how many believed it. Some still believe it, but I can't help that.

medsbluerose
6/3/2021 12:18:11 pm

Way to go RD Duttine👍🕊️🌿

Alexander Sore Nose
10/27/2021 10:21:22 pm

Michael Vecsey can't understand that a bj is "sexual relations". I can't take anything he says seriously after that. The mind of a child is not prepared to perceive the world of men. (I jest. We know he understood perfectly well and only set out to decieve. He is of the mind that once you are painted with the broad brushes of racism and antisemitism, you can never be correct. He is not gentleman nor scholar.) AND as for the author of this diatribe we are commenting on, he fully understands that Robert meant that Aryans RE-introduced agriculture to the New World, but, as these dishonest folk who propagate the narrative that steals the heritage of millions of people like to conduct themselves, he will point out anything that can be intentionally misunderstood knowing the lay reader will gobble it up without thinking twice. I didnt read the whole thing. Once I have detected dishonesty in one's work, there is no sense in poisoning my own mind with their lies. I apologize to R D DUTTINE for replying to their post but Michael Vecsey's post doesn't have the ability to respond to it. Good day, Gents. (those of you who can proudly count themselves among the truth telling gentlemen of the world)

medsbluerose
6/3/2021 12:15:34 pm

Are you one of the folks running out to get jabbed without researching the data? Research things before making a fool of yourself.

Average IQ
5/11/2023 11:31:24 am

So you debate his rational with the exact statement he stated you would

"My government education doesn't allow me to hold that viewpoint"

You can just use basic English, most people aren't that divided by their understanding of Esoterica.

Let's see what works you've created Andy, oh, just as much plagiarism and speculation as any writer - but somehow different when it's government PROPOGANDA framed as FACT.

If all humans come from one general ancestor our blood wouldn't reject one another's.

Please consider medication or euthanasia.

Uncle Ron
11/22/2016 06:55:31 pm

Link below shows sea level 394 feet below current level during the last Ice Age. The general global map looks pretty much like it does today (that surprised me) and there is definitely no land mass in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean.

https://www.iceagenow.com/Sea_Level_During_Last_Ice_Age.htm

J quinn
3/12/2017 09:32:14 pm

You noobs think that 400 feet of height = 400 feet of volume. Go back to the basics. This "teacher" should not be instructing anyone. Especially with such clear biases.

Pat the Truthseeker
9/1/2020 10:41:24 am

Do more research on the topic.
They Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis, based on the Younger Dryas Boundary layer shows that the pleistocene era ended with rapid melting of the North American glacial ice sheet. If 2 miles of ice that covered millions of square miles melts rapidly, not only does it disperse an enormous amount of water, but it also relieves a significant amount of weight load off of the Earth's mantle. This melting of these polar caps relieves a tremendous amount of pressure on the North American continent and will cause recession in other parts of the planet much like when a balloon is squeezed and then released.
Many pre-glacial maps I've seen show the Mid-Atlantic ridge raised and places like Bimini Road above water. Also, dredging along the Azores sea floor which is well below 400 feet under sea level turned up sediment ONLY found above water.
There is a lot of scientific findings from the early 1900's that have been ignored in order to push the out-of-Africa illogical theory.
We are finding human remains in North America that are 130,000 years old completely destroying the Clovis "first" theory that is STILL being taught in schools all over.
Just because academia tells us what is "true" doesn't mean it necessarily is. And when they continue to ignore new scientific evidence, the conspiracy theory is proven true that they are forcing an agenda instead of the facts.

Denise
11/23/2016 12:28:32 pm

The Mid-Atlantic Ridge precludes any possibility of a large land mass in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean.

No brains
3/12/2017 09:35:05 pm

And do you know how ridges and ranges are formed? Have you heard of plate tectonics?

Michael Vecsey
4/6/2019 03:43:16 pm

Lol. Pay attention. There is proof there is no land mass 400 feet below the surface where robert s claims.

Pat the Truthseeker
9/1/2020 10:45:34 am

Mike,
You're ignoring the strong possibility that when the North American ice sheet melted 11,600 years ago it removed an immense amount of stress on the earth's crust and mantle which caused the area below the ice sheets to rise, while subsequently causing other parts of the globe to receed beyond the sole meltwater pulse that rose the ocean level 400 feet in a very short time.

Will
10/10/2020 02:37:52 am

If so, then the much spoken continents for "Mu" or "Lemuria", which seems to be the same area named twice, are probably the sunken continent where Atlantis is located. Technically, both are reached by boat by first sailing through the Straight of Gibraltar a, "Gates of Hercules".

Mu & Lemuria, according to legend, sunk into the ocean. Atlantis & Mu sunk into the sea, rose out of the water, & sunk into it again. Also, Mu & Lemuria are as large as Plato described. Atlantis could just be a large city on either continent. Just because Plato said Atlantis was past the Gates of Hercules doesn't mean it was just outside the gates or in the same ocean. If the lost continent sunk, it is reason why the Himalaya rose hundreds of feet, & is why sea shells are found near the tops of mountains there.

Also, ancient advanced civilizations of the Americas & Asian could've been created by the remnants of Lemuria & Mu. Watch Robert sepehr's video of chinese pyramids. It's possible that refugees from the lost continent started ancient Egypt, like they probably did in China first. Robert spoke of US Air Force WW2 pilot flying over the chinese pyramid tuwt is larger than any in Egypt. Its capstone was describe as jewel-like, & the pyramid's sides were bright white. If the pilot told the US government most likely, American members of y illuminati or freemasons bought it from then-poor China, & made china cover it up with tons of dirt, shrubs, & trees.

Jaap
11/24/2016 12:57:03 pm

Flabberghasted. This may surprise you Andy, but when I go inside myself I can find absolutely nothing to match this racist crap. As a youth I read about these Nazi ideas (Himmler mostly, I take it), and took it at face value: OK, there are funny ideas in the world. Some of them sinister and very destructive ... Now I'm old and I know I must be connected to this idiocy somehow, or else I wouldn't be reading it. It just doesn't go away Reading McCormac helps me focus a bit, but that's probably a step too far: it seems more undeep than that (your Roman sword gave me that angle, for which Thanks! plus withdrawal of criticism).
Why is obligatry health-insurance un-American? Oh Andy, why did you vote for Trump? Because of a gut-feeling he may turn out half-decent? Make America great again, as Hitler did Germany (Autobahn, Volkswagon, career-opportunities for poor people)? Where did this come from, and where does this lead us?
Oh my America! It's bad enough as it is in Europe.
As instruction material it seems a bit over the top (this guy is serious??). But that's all you need to show going from the brass tacks.
I think I like your work, and will check on what you will come up next.
Rereading this post it seems totally irrelevant, pointing out things understood by everyone. But I waste nothing by posting it anyhow ...

Guru
2/26/2018 12:35:58 pm

And what does any of this have to do with the debate about the merits, or lack thereof, of the book? Yeah, it is irrelevant.

Johnson
2/1/2017 11:19:43 am

"None of those claims is supported by evidence."
-fifth full paragraph. Fifth sentence

"None of those claims are supported by evidence" would be the proper way of saying this.

ely
3/15/2017 03:38:45 pm

No. "None of these claims is supported by evidence" is correct. "None" means "not ONE", and is therefore singular. You don't have to beleive me. Look it up in any reputable grammar book or college grammar website under "Subject Verb Agreement".

Davie
3/29/2017 05:37:04 am

"i" before "e" except after "c"

Guru
2/26/2018 12:37:00 pm

believe, not beleive

Efy
11/2/2018 09:32:24 pm

It's not "no one" it's "not one".

'None of these claims (plural) are supported by evidence' is correct

Not quite
10/14/2017 11:49:32 pm

None is derived from a contraction of not one.

One is. Not one is. None is.

The original sentence would be the proper way of saying this.

ED
4/21/2020 02:46:02 pm

None is the subject of the sentence , thence is is the correct form of the verb .

Greg
2/22/2017 11:59:58 am

I agree Atlantis is wrong but actually there is some truth in this work that is yet to be uncovered. There are blue eyed mummies in Peru (cloud people) and in China (Tocharians). There was undoubtedly a lost higher civilization of people who were light skinned and light eyes and hair who brought a lot of civilization around the world. I mean the oldest mummy ever found in Egypt is called "ginger" because of its red hair. That is not racism. Some of it is quite true.

michael mifsud
7/9/2017 12:47:17 pm

I often wonder why those scathing attacks on obviously more intelligent writers, are allowed on these forums. Personal notes on why people are racists and how dark their inner selves are etc. are typical in many blogs. I think they call them trolls because they try to undermine others and cause indignation. However if its of any consolation, these accusers obviously spend most of their "valuable?" time feeding into forums to attack anything that makes them feel uncomfortable, However, all good debates should only allow sensible argument because otherwise readers will simply not get back to the pages.
I venture to say, that if Japan went under, the same would be said of them in their exploits all over the world if they did not all go down with it. Their ingenuity and colossal economic success after getting blown to smithereens apart form the disasters, is admirable. Their country is a string of islands. The near surface mountain ridges in the Atlantic would create enough island space to harbour a civilization and the Atlantis theory would not be that far off the mark. There is also the question of the centrifugal effect of overloaded poles which has given rise to the magnetic pole interchanges theories and that of the slide of this so called Atlantean plateau which ties in with the climate cores drilled in the Antarctic. They point to the place having been somewhere else at the time in the palm leaves strata - or the equator was somewhere else at the time. There is no proof for or against it, but the way it came to us and over two thousand years ago when nobody every thought (according to the literature of the periods) about things like lost civilizations, there is a ring of truth that has kept it all alive until today. I have no shadow of doubt about previous civilizations, as the tunnel networks in India and the Sumerian and Egyptian civilizations appear to imply, but whether we will find enough solid material to establish it, remains to be seen. None of this has anything to do with racism and the only people who appear to use that word so vociferously every time Aryans come up may feel they have a right to, but does this mean that discussing Neanderthals for example with over 1500 ccm brains makes them feel uncomfortable too ?

Jorge Pereira
10/13/2021 06:35:23 am

No land mass in that area???
You are sure what you are saying, i'm Portuguese, I've been to the islands of the azores and seen more than 400 pyramids located there, I heard about the gigantic pyramid that is at the bottom of the sea that was discovered by a fisherman with a sonar, both the ancestors of azores and Canary Islands talk about a huge island off its coast that disappeared after a cataclysm, and Plato wasn't the first person to talk about Atlantis, you should know better.
Maybe if you go diving one day near the islands of the Azores, you'll change your mind!

Bob Jase
2/22/2017 12:05:56 pm

http://www.livescience.com/48384-ancient-redhead-myth.html

because the google can be your friend.

Greg
2/22/2017 12:09:10 pm

Yep if it's on google it's gotta be true! Good call!

Bob Jase
2/22/2017 12:15:03 pm

Don't wear yourself out by doing any research or anything.

Kate
12/8/2017 01:50:04 pm




Neardentals were red.
is genetically proven.

Red-Headed Neanderthals
Ancient DNA has been used to show aspects of Neanderthal appearance. A fragment of the gene for the melanocortin 1 receptor (MRC1) was sequenced using DNA from two Neanderthal specimens from Spain and Italy: El Sidrón 1252 and Monte Lessini (Lalueza-Fox et al. 2007). MCR1 is a receptor gene that controls the production of melanin, the protein responsible for pigmentation of the hair and skin. Neanderthals had a mutation in this receptor gene which changed an amino acid, making the resulting protein less efficient and likely creating a phenotype of red hair and pale skin. (The reconstruction below of a male Neanderthal by John Gurche features pale skin, but not red hair) .How do we know what this phenotype would have looked like? Modern humans display similar mutations of MCR1, and people who have two copies of this mutation have red hair and pale skin. However, no modern human has the exact mutation that Neanderthals had, which means that both Neanderthals and humans evolved this phenotype independent of each other.

Kate
12/8/2017 01:58:59 pm

idiot, Neanderthal bodies were not found with hair. DNA tests proved that they had clear skin and red hair in life.

http://humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/genetics/ancient-dna-and-neanderthals/dna-genotypes-and-phenotypes

Bad biased teacher
3/12/2017 09:38:57 pm

I hope you didn't ruin the critical thinking of your pupils with your vile biases and unfounded opinions. It is disgusting to think people with your stunted mental capacity are responsible for shaping the minds of our youth.

michael mifsud canilla
4/20/2017 12:30:28 pm

I find these kinds of critical analyses of peoples work repugnant because they betray prejudice. Academic prejudice in particular is particularly abhorrent and often makes you wonder whether they wish they had got there first. The book fits in with what many of us think probably happened and it is a well known fact that there is a great to sort out genetically to enable us to come to grips with age old dicta based on Darwin which does not explain the world we have today. If the author is to be attacked because of what he suggests might be an answer based on his findings, then attack that. Are these so called overwhelmingly erudite editors saying that his genetic marker findings are all wrong ? That the author is not qualified ? The same thing happened to anyone who dared to suggest that Neanderthal Man got into the gene chain and it was obvious at a mere glance that he was around and that we could not see the wood for the trees.

I suggest that these peeved so called critics read the book as I did - with an open mind and establish whether Sepehr basic research is wrong before going out and criticising the peripheral outlines suggested by these. I for one having studied as much as I could about prehistoric legends and archeological findings of subterranean communities, not to mention biblical anecdotes, know he is getting us somewhere and that the tracks are laid for more conclusive evidence. Published findings recently commented on the lack of concentration of most of the inherited human genes as opposed to that of a few. It was suggested that it meant that huge amounts of people to the point of extinction in some cases of race or identity, had disappeared and probably in great calamities. Is this not what it is all about ?

I imagine we have religiously tainted academic lobbies aghast at the thought that all that fancy divine intervention treaties would be cast in the shadows among others who just jump on anything that dares to suggest alternative trails.

Guru
2/26/2018 12:44:19 pm

I agree. His review would have been a lot more salient had he left the the racial diatribes. I don't think any of that was necessary to discredit the work, at least not in that vein. He was essentially calling Sepehr a racist. Unnecessary and anti-intellectual.

Brina
2/4/2021 08:42:33 am

I agree but I did a search on Robert S. I did come across sites and social media with tons of comments that he has made that could be considered by most reasonable persons to be prejudice or racist. The comments on twitter was dishearting to see especially since I like his youtube channel and like watching his vids in my nephilim/worldwide pyramids/ancient alien/Sumerian/pre-christian research. Just researching scientific racism exposed me to many of same type of ideas that are oddly similar (even in terminology).Still gonna watch his vids as the other topics are useful.

Marcus
4/26/2021 12:45:47 am

The whole purpose of Sepehr's argument is to represent Sub-Saharan African peoples as an entirely different, an inferior, species to modern man.Sepehr is a racist.

Cowbhoy
5/17/2017 01:09:30 pm

How rude and very closed minded, no one really knows our history with any high degree of acuracy with it getting foggier the further you go back to a stage were the days of Jesus and beyond are all handed down myths, what he claims is very possible, he may get some things wrong or he may get it all wrong but what he claims is a possiblity just like the stories in the bible are possible too or that maybe the lost antiduluvian civilisation may have been in antartica or an atlantis....You can take positives from anything if you have your eyes open to see it or you can have a destructive and antidiverse mindset and burn it in the dumpster like they done with the witches..!!

michael mifsud canilla
5/17/2017 01:48:26 pm

People like Sepher and especially journalists as opposed to academics open up more possibilities than all that prejudiced stuff based on nonsensical idiotic, legendary claims. The book is not about Atlantis but about genetics and their trails. I would have never questioned the ape ascent to man had it not been for Sepher and I have spent many years of my life digging out material that can show light on the reality of biblical evens. All that this very highly polished writers has said is logical and astonishing. He makes no claims but suggests that since Atlantis coincides with these trails in their clusters across both sides of the Atlantic it was worth throwing it in. Having researched much about the Basques and Berbers without taking into account all that has been written about them (not forgetting the Guanchis), it does not surprise me. However, there is a great deal more to come now that that biblical reality shows are beggining to emerge. The question of the truth of the Ashkenazi and the Exodus - the nature of the tribes of Israel and the tribe of Judah (with different Gods), is all now coming out to the foreground. So is the question of Neanderthal presence in our genetic makeup which was denied to the point of hysteria by the prejudiced academic world. Portugal has very important sites to dig into yet- especially around the area the Templars settled on and which I personally believe will put a different emphasis on the question of the Temple that was never in Jerusalem etc.
Thank God for the likes of Sepher and Velicovsky among others. At least the angle is clean and interesting and provides more answers than questions. I suggest it should be recommended to intelligent friends and told that the Atlantis question is a side issue which makes the book more than just a few pages of very disturbing/enlightening facts.

Dumpster fire ? extinguisher ?
6/1/2017 02:14:34 am

Thanks Gawd for you Andy White! I stumbled upon this NeoNazi white supremacist trash talker on YouTube - I'm intrigued by ancient history and saw a few thumbnails featuring beautiful gardens, Basque people and Berber tribes... so I clicked and I found out very quickly that indeed with his oh so monotone ... seemingly benevolent voice this man is a raging pseudo science spewing Nazi.

I love to call out racists because they are delusional and are unaware that in fact racism is a mental disorder based on a Schizoaffective condition. They truly believe they are superior and that thought rules their world view and perceptions.

This man is very ethnic looking and I would venture to say he might have internalized some self hatred- most racist hate something about themselves and project that very hatred unto other cultures.

He goes on to ask people to join him on the journey to discover the lost truth. Really? What is horrid about his channel is that some poor lost souls are latching on to this charlatan's "independent studies" and believe what he is spewing.

He's a joke and I'm shocked more people haven't denounced him.

will
7/9/2017 10:40:53 am

You are full of hate and bigotry yourself by your very statements. You are a racist then

Guru
2/26/2018 12:52:03 pm

I don't much agree with you at first glance, but I am open-minded. I would be very interested in the studies you can provide to back your opinions. Don't get me wrong, I don't support racism, but I do know psychology, and this is the first that I have heard that it is a symptom of a schizoaffective disorder (which, according to many psychiatric scholars, is inherited). Racism is more of a learned attitude than a disorder.

Dan
9/29/2019 11:10:42 am

"Racism" is a political epithet crafted by Trotsky in furtherance of class warfare. Until very recently, it was considered self-evident that A) there are different races, or distinct "breeds" of human beings, and B) that these breeds, as one might expect, differ greatly in their temperaments and capacities. We have reached a pass (imagine an overpass in the shape of a pretzel) where all distinct races ("ethnicities" if you'd rather) are - socially and politically - encouraged to take great pride in their histories and achievements, but one race is expressly forbidden to do so. This race is "the racist race" - even when flagellating themselves and canting their "so sorry" self-abasement to the heavens. When the term "racism" is used, it is therefore ever and always self-cancelling. It exposes the user of the term. And if you'll notice, it is usually accompanied by an hysterical outburst, and the declaration of some violent or censorious impulse. "Dumpster fire," indeed.

Y'all wild
9/10/2020 08:17:34 pm

I know people with schizophrenia and like disorders and trust me he is not a skitzo lol one of them kept telling me he had anal worms and parasites and he needs to keep vials of his blood in the fridge so he can rejuvenate himself and every couple months he either slits his throat or cuts his arms up to the point where it looks like he lost a fight with a bear. Lol. Totally different ballpark

Y'all wild
9/10/2020 08:12:13 pm

Y'all wild. Most of you play that racist card cuzz the tv is in your head. All day everyday I watch the people around me let the mass media get into their heads and they are left with a closed mind and an additude that's synonymous with the very prejudice and hate they are supposedly are pissing and moaning about. Most people at this level are upset on some subconscious level and they take to the internet to crucify anything that they judge to be against their view of morality (which is really the view of morality and the world around them that the media has set up for them)

Vrilia
12/22/2020 08:06:56 pm

Robert Sepehr is right on. And you my friend are an envious fool.

Kiwi
6/20/2017 07:26:00 am

Thanks - your review of this pro aryan nazi was enlightening

David Lazarus link
6/20/2017 12:14:38 pm

I was a friend of the late Dr Lewis E Graham. Author of the Gnosis Onward series. I am curious as to what you think of this work; which is based on over four decades of research.

David Lazarus link
6/20/2017 12:15:37 pm

>his work

Renee
7/3/2017 11:31:17 am

Truth is an interesting concept. We should always be open to listen. If its not to your like then so be it. If it is then so be it.
To some who say its "racist". I've known racist of all races, creeds, etc. Denouncing one does not make it so. Only one can make that decision for their self.
So be kind and realize governments have decided long ago to skew history to support their narrative.
Remember their running a nation of millions of people. Whether that is good or bad is a completely different story.

michael mifsud canilla
7/3/2017 01:10:31 pm

Truth is truth but it depends on the base from which it springs as to whether it is universal. Any cultural belief will have its own form of truth but if they have a common ethical base, then the truth will beal the the same. It is only when it is slanted to fit into personal beliefs or prejudice, that it ceases to have the value required to bring people together within natural needs. The Gods might be vastly different with individual aspirations preached by their representatives, but if the criteria on which they are based are identical . e.g. love or respect for all living creatures then those truths arrived at, will easily merge with one another like the tidal waves among the rocks.

It is the ability to discern absolute truths that inspire many to dedicate their lives to influencing others to pay heed and change their ways.

Sepher does it very well within the limits of his understandings whilst others merely utilize rhetoric and burlesque to show simply how clever they are and not to prove their own counter points.

The book is a turning point in the concept of human origins and any genuinely intelligent person can see it straight away. Killing mythical concepts simply because they have been called ludicrous and fanciful in the past is to deny all new interpretations and supportive new findings which genetics are now pouring out. Nothing is proven without definitive evidence and those who have not met and mingled with modern Guanchis, Berbers and Basque people, should shut shop and talk about other things rather than fill these boxes with such despicable and dismissive diatribe. Because of these sweeping theatrical approaches to good material, much has been left undone that could by now give us good frameworks to come to important conclusions about our origins. It is after all, loathsome scorn. I scoured every page and statement as a professional writer and diehard investigator. It was what any piece of research with modern valuable instruments should be - a rare and exciting line of thought that brings promise of much more to come about our mangled and confusing prehistorical horizons.

I

Anth student
7/12/2017 07:38:45 pm

Andy,

I'd like to thank you and the students for taking the time to evaluate this book. I didn't read it, but I saw several videos made by the author that drew me here. All the videos cover basically what you are describing above and people are believing it.

OpticNervana
7/15/2017 02:42:11 pm

I look at it this way, science defines "species"..not nature..racists/believers in the idea of separate "races" define "race" not scientists. Then of course if nature can spontaneously generate(because no way they have a common mammal ancestors right?) different "species" of humankind across the globe, why then must we assume that anyone with blue eye came from a single clan of humanoid that spread every example of advanced technology and culture to whoever they met in return for authority..but then were conveniently, in most cases chased or bred out entirely to the point that their collectivized legacy(as they of course like all other "races" we're of one mind and therefore can claim 100% shared credit for any achievement someone who looked like them might produce) now only exists as cave art and oral ghost stories? Almost as if to say if you didn't have blue eyes and or ginger colored hair you could relax and take no interest in technological advancement of your community.

MICHAEL MIFSUD
7/16/2017 06:04:56 am

Sepher is being misunderstood as so many others, like Velikovsky, Osman, Allegro etc - with alternative ideas, are. He does not say Atlantis exists. He merely uses the story as a possible origin of much which without it, stands unexplained. There is no doubt about the superior race because of the finesse of the instruments found and the size and colour of eyes together with the cranial volumes, associated with them. There is also the self description of the Berbers about their original physiology as well as that of the Basques etc. All have similar historical echoes of places like Troy, Sparta etc. which at least puts them back to Greece. There is no doubt about their existence even if we do not know who they were and we are told not only by Sephr that blue eyes and blonde hair among other things are "recessive" which means that if one of them married a dark haired black eyed mongoloid for examples, as happened with the Basques, the children would be mainly dark. Blue eyed blond tall types would emerge through the centuries in a small proportion as is seen today in these ethnic groupings, but essentially it would almost disappear. The Neanderthal dna could not be seen simply because it seems that the male Neanderthals mated with female Cro Magnons (because their women had became sterile through hybridisation?) or because they were more attractive or were offered them because the Cro Magnon males had a similar problem ?. We shall know eventually. Now we know that the Neanderthals from part of our heritage, the percentage will gradually become clear through alternative genetic methods. We have two very strange but explicit "myths" which come close to a possible understanding of just what happened in our early days. The Benjamites of Israel and the leading race, were derived of a very white, blonde and blue eyed child accused of being the issue of the Elohim or "Gods" and even Jacob was alarmed because of this (we are told). When the tribes of Israel led by Judah turned on the Benjamites, they killed all their women and eventually, as a result of grief it seems they were allowed to have children of the Sabeans or Shiloh which is the same thing. It was an attempt to darken their issue and remove their Aryan appearance which the Judeans, as an Ethiopian tribe (as was also Benjamin) resented and were jealous of. There cannot be any other explanation for the sentence. The same happens mysteriously with the founders of Rome who were forced also to sire children of the Sabines "rape of the Sabines" whilst their husbands were drunk and unconscious. Very similar stories with only one explanation - to remove the physiology of a people condemned by their appearance. Additionally, it is known that the Etruscans married into the Villanovans and they were the founders of the Romans and came from a race called the Carians or people of the CAR. It is also known that the CAR or CRC as they are known and which letters appear in many of their descendants, were Godlike so there is something also that makes one wonder what was being hidden as many of their descendants were proud to have come from. I do not think there is any doubt about the existence of these people and about their contribution. It is up to the open minded and honest researchers to consider why it does not want to be seen. There are countless channels which open up to them but there are others who do not want their own makeup to be considered beneath the real claimants to the ancient Aryans. There is also the question of the Germanic races and the Prussians who have dominated our Royal families and who are supposed to come form the Merovingians. Surely such detailed and enigmatic anecdotes cannot be brushed aside as mere drug driven nonsense as some would think. Atlantis stands in the same corridors of prehistory and the more it is pushed away the stronger the urge to examine it becomes.

Dave
7/23/2017 10:33:09 am

Interesting. I think the author has been reading the Lacerta files and expanding within his books. Im open minded to human development as our evolution is very quick and as effectively we only developed things such as the wheel in recent history (post pyramid construction whenever this actually happened) Writing is also only very recent combined with our love for religion and gods which stems from lack of knowledge and understanding. We are a new species in the state of the cosmos and over time may may understand our embryonic place through open mindedness. Time will tell, but I will be long gone before that.

Mark Hazlewood
10/10/2017 01:32:32 pm

Robert Sepehr has been spamming his YouTube videos all around and I am so glad to have found Andy White's review of his book. This guy is an odd mixture of pseudoscience and neoNazi/white supremacist and what Andy writes doesn't surprise me at all.

Michael Mifsud Canilla
10/10/2017 02:27:15 pm

I spent my whole life reading and writing about practically anything that required others to put in their little grain of sand however irritable it could be to some. My shelves buckle under the load of mainly best sellers which said something new and provoked all to read everything else on the market that could add weight to the arguments. Today, Castaneda, Von Daniken, Lobsang Rampa,Dawkins among other awesome reads of the time, would be trolled over by the likes of these petty so called seneca´s who add nothing except show their obvious prejudice by running it all down with every available piece of timber lying around. Their arguments show a much more inclined "propaganda dismissal factor" than the book by Sepehr has allusions which do no more than bring curious facts together to point in a direction we all know is sadly far too hazy to come to any conclusions about. Sepehr does what I do in my writings - bring curious things together and get coordinates that point in a direction that many, for instinctive reasons,know has to be there. These attacks are boorish and an insult to the likes of the author who demonstrates a calmer, more intelligent vision of a likelihood which is exciting many. Why dont these pally pally real pseudo´s write their own books and find out if they provoke the same reactions ?

Who cares if Atlantis did not exist in the manner and form described so subtly by a third hand recipient of the comments, like Plato ? Who cares if these "Gods" were far ahead in the human game ? But who can explain how those cave paintings can be so ingeniously elaborate for such a brutish people or why the full spectrum of genetic markers which are known to have existed have been reduced to such a narrow choice ? Why were Neanderthallers so undermined by modern academics until very recently when it is now obvious that we form a part of their legacy ? Sepehr has made millions think again and that is what matters. I hope with all my heart that he goes further because this is just a mere sample of what he is capable of putting together and we want to know.

Guru
2/26/2018 01:00:06 pm

Excellent points. Thank you for your open-minded input.

Mary reynolds
10/31/2017 04:07:10 pm

OK just got my DNA report and I'm 75% Neanderthal with blue eyes light hair and ANeg blood. But most importantly VERY GLAD HITLER AND HIS ILK LOST THE WAR... get it ROBERT?

Charlotte Beattie
11/9/2017 04:01:03 pm

I have been watching his viedeos all day. This is the first I have heard of him. I have heard a lot of this information from other sources. I think he is on to something. I have enjoy watching them. I have not read his books. I’m surprised he hasn’t gotten into the Summarian text and interpretation by Zachariah Stitchen.

Mark Hazelwood
11/10/2017 10:13:32 am

Before Sepehr claimed to be an anthropologist he put out videos on the Planet X in 2003 scam which was based very loosely on Zecharia Sitchin. They were popular for a short time, however since there was a specific date that came and went the profit went out of the whole Nibiru thing. And really Sitchin's interpretations were very "creative" and supported by no Sumerian scholars. Sitchin's books were a bit of a dumpster fire as well. At least Sitchin didn't have the blatant racism in his books that Sepehr puts into his books and videos.

Dan
9/29/2019 11:28:43 am

Actually Sitchin took specific, objectionable liberties in his translation, which did not undermine his overall thesis - that the Sumerian "gods," the Annuna, were real beings, and created humanity as their slaves. Gerald Clark uses authoritative translations very effectively to reach the same conclusions as Sitchin - and more.

We're so sick of the "anti-racist," PC gatekeepers of a fallen academy, strutting and scowling at we, the hoi polloi, as if truth were a commodity that they, and they only, might dispense (for an enormous fee). To hell with them. They're past their pull-by date and have clearly gone rotten.

TexaSean link
7/19/2018 06:41:36 pm

Seems to me, a lot of people in these comments, have no idea what they speak of. Can you give me absolute proof Atlantis did not exist? That’s like asking to show me a Higgs Boson, you can’t. No matter how badly you want to believe otherwise.
Just like you can’t show me a photo of earth from space, that isn’t photoshopped. Give you $1,000 American if you can.

Andy White
7/26/2018 11:00:48 am

Can you give me absolute proof there's not a teapot orbiting the sun?

You can follow the link below to see a photo of the Earth taken from the moon in 1968. It appeared in many publications prior to 1988, when Photoshop was first invented. You can send the check to my office.

https://newatlas.com/gallery-photograph-earth-from-space/50704/

Erdem
9/11/2020 08:45:50 am

Interesting.

Do you mean to say photoshop was invented editing software and nothing was used before it? i.e. released public as soon as it was invented - in other words it was the first editing software ever and when it was made, it wasn't held in secret but rather released directly outside?

Sounds like the invention of internet history backstory ^_^

Michael Vecsey
4/8/2019 06:24:02 am

Lol. Pre photoshop there are pics of eArth from space. You are deeply confused.

Moira
8/22/2018 10:24:02 pm

Also I saw a video that Steve-O took when he went up there recently. But it just "looks" round.
Sepher does seem to speak fondly of Nazis and negatively about Jews. But he also talked about operation paperclip which seems like it would be anti-nazi... Has anyone just plainly called him out for seeming like he looks up to the nazis?

Jean Paul
9/3/2018 07:10:06 pm

Sepehr boots people from his Facebook page and deletes comments on YouTube he doesn't like. It seems 20 years ago he was putting out Nibiru videos so he has a lot of experience avoiding being called on his BS.

Marcus
4/26/2021 01:06:03 am

I believe that he also blocks people on Twitter.

Dan
9/29/2019 11:36:10 am

Goody-good vs. baddy-bad. Goo-goo, ga-ga. Mommy, look at me, I'm GOOD. Good boys always say good things about the good people. Only BAD boys say good things about the bad people...(etc.)

This is the mentality of hysterical denunciation of "racism" and "Nazis." This is the mentality of victim-worship. It is the mentality that fetishizes blacks for being black and denounces whites for being white. It isn't doing anything to fight totalitarian government and racial genocide - on the contrary, it is a mirror image of Nazism, and very likely to result in these woeful outcomes.

Caro
4/2/2020 01:05:27 am

Yaaaaasssss! Finally someone with some sense.
Everyone who is pissed about this guy’s excellent work is crippingly mainstream. Robert isn’t even that deep into conspiracy. The rabbit hole goes so much deeper. Flat earth? Resets? Mud flood anyone?

Human
7/22/2020 06:32:19 pm

Robert Sepehr is not even a Anthropologist.

Human 2
7/22/2020 06:34:17 pm

It's also really easy to just type in a new name and make a new comment btw.

Foo Fighter
8/23/2018 07:38:44 am

We can hold two ideas in mind at one time.

One idea is that there is a lot of intriguing evidence of a pre-civilization(s) (of some sort). Words, concepts, iconography a world apart speak to "something" big we are missing.

The other thing to keep in mind is that we just don't have enough information to fill in the details of our pre-history. Anyone expressing any certainty is jumping the gun.

I applaud the author and others that bring up many VERY interesting pieces of information pointing to a pre-civilization. He, like Sitchin and others, take what they have way too far though which sullies what SHOULD be a very serious line of inquiry.

Hawwa
9/26/2018 11:01:17 am

Isn't Aryan more like a phenotype than a race? Nazis didn't even consider Slavs human, and Slavs have light skin, hair and eyes. It was because of their racial phenotype. For someone who makes tons of videos about Nazis, he sure doesn't know anything about them.
I'm Cushite myself and he even tries to make people believe white people are native to Nubia. I'm honestly tired of this afro and eurocentric propaganda videos all over the internet. Nubians are Hamitic, we have nothing in common with West Africans, except our skin color.
Why is it only black and white Westerners making these stupid claims? I have never seen a Japanese, Slavic, Polynesian, etc... person claim that they are ancient Egyptians.

Y'all wild
9/10/2020 08:35:49 pm

Americans are raised ignorant that's why

Bingo Pyjama
11/5/2021 01:48:20 pm

The truth hurts.

Noz
10/15/2018 08:24:58 am

Let me guess, Robert is an anthropologist in the same way I'm an astrophysicist....

Crackpot.

Grim
12/8/2018 02:12:02 am

Atlantis seems to have been where the Eye of the Sahara is, not in yon ocean. Kinda neat.

Tracy
1/7/2019 12:41:56 pm

I wandered in to a couple of his YouTube videos (not knowing who he was) and found myself genuinely confused. There was no straight line of any type of information. His "facts" would wander into unrelated anecdotes that made no sense but seemed to back up some vague ideology. almost as if he was trying very hard not to appear to represent any type of white supremacy. However, the proliferation of swastikas in his videos and his focus on the Aryans were obvious dog whistles. I can, however, understand a little more clearly where people can be tricked by these subtleties into believing that, for instance, all Muslims are bad. Just show some video of Isis men laughing about female (blond, blue eyed) sex slaves or blowing up ancient artifacts and you have a case for ANY anti Muslim sentiment. They must ALL be terrorists! Look at these evil people! I'm fairly well educated and intelligent, so I was able, fairly quickly, to suspect there was something off about these videos. Reading the comments, I understood how people could be indoctrinated into his clearly anti Muslim, anti Semitic beliefs. His videos (and mind you, I only barely watched two) were less like presenting facts and more like answering anticipated questions to back up his assertions (vague as they were). Subliminal manipulation at it's....well, not best, but certainly a heroic effort. If nothing else, it was an anthropological treatise into how easily people can be gulled into ideas of racial supremacy, perhaps without even realizing it. It's said for every argument you can find ten types of proof for either side. I would conclude that many white supremacists could point to these videos as absolute proof of their beliefs and be thoroughly convinced that he has provided scientific research to back it up. Never mind the research is faulty at best, it's on the internet so it must be true.

Dan
9/29/2019 11:41:29 am

Islam is what it is. The Quran says what it says. Muhammad is who he was, and what is believed about his "supreme example" is what it is. One may point to Muslims who are not very Muslim and we may all agree that they are nice people. But Islam is what it is. And the Western world has reason to fear it.

Dzie
3/31/2019 01:01:28 pm

I have been with the flu and Youtubing on the couch all day and in my stupor watching this Robert Sepehr. After about 7 clips I noticed he used the phrase "Amercian pro-afrocentric views" which had me scratching my head because, in Canada, America have more of a reputation for killing off their Black citizens. Then I come across a video where he states "German Jews were put in Zionist camps run Zionist Jew and the gas chambers were used to sterilize clothing from lice and the Jews were given their money and assets back" In each video he seems to spit out the word Jew. Combined, these observations got me off the couch to my laptop and landed me here because I felt lolled into this guy's racist anti-semetic diatribes. When talking about the end of WW2 he discusses the suffering of the "Germans getting carpet bombed, civilians nuked in Japan, and the Jews who did not get to participate in the transfer agreement(!)"

Sean link
4/7/2019 01:27:57 pm

They Jews went to war with germany first. The Jews were covered in lice and that needed to be dealt with.And when did canada kill of black citizens? I missed this part of history and am am curious.

Michael Vecsey
4/7/2019 03:41:33 pm

Lol. The jews went to war vs the nazis first? You clearly are a moronic racist

Dan
9/29/2019 11:50:28 am

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhFRGDyX48c&fbclid=IwAR0QlT0iLgMFmT8ZAFkwmSg8B12tl7tm7Mc7mZejj8OSB9NjztZBg5TZbR8

sean
4/7/2019 10:52:35 pm

Not a Nazi, but the LEFT has definitely made me seriously consider it.
Here is a little history for ya, numb nuts..
https://www.wintersonnenwende.com/scriptorium/english/archives/articles/jdecwar.html

Sean
4/7/2019 10:58:17 pm

OH WAIT, that dumb ass called me racist, for saying Jews started the war. HOW is that racist? And sorry, I thought he called me a nazi, im so used to it these days. Here is another lesson, The IRISH, also went through a holocaust, wanna talk about that one? People don't get tossed in jail in England, or banned from Facebook for talking about THAT genocide. Fuck, people act like Jews are some magical creatures we cant talk about.. Guess what, people like me are getting educated,and sick of the lies...

Dan
9/29/2019 11:59:29 am

Yes, these people are mostly Communists (by any other name) and they are turning the academy, and public discourse, to absolute shit - by design. They are ultimately led by Frankist/Sabbateans - which topic Sepehr has covered admirably in another book, "1666: Redemption Through Sin." But they are not "Jews" (read 1666). They are nihilists, serving the "Great Mother" - i.e., darkness personified. Their goal is entirely negative, and driven by people - Rothschilds, Weishaupt, Frank and their intellectual and biological heirs - who wish to negate all humanity and civilization. Their merely degenerate followers and agents (whom they despise) are motivated by self-interest and the hope of some eventual Candyland world of self-gratification with no rules. But the controllers want to burn everything down and install a "technocracy." A human ant farm. "Brave New World," *1984," "This Perfect Day" - all LEAKS, from insiders, who KNEW.

Michael Vecsey
4/8/2019 06:04:43 am

Is it fun being misinformed and racist? 1. Read hitlers book. The jewish boycott was deserved. 2. It was not an act of war you twit. Boycotts are declared regularly and in no way are they acts of war. You seem to have only a high school education. 3. You need to better research the boycott to avoid embarrassing yourself again. Start here and then read the links at the bottom of the page. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Nazi_boycott_of_1933

Sean
4/11/2019 10:02:03 am

I hate Wiki.... If you like to read, since your all educated and stuff, and I seem to have only a high school education, try this. http://www.sweetliberty.org/issues/israel/freedman.htm

Sean
4/11/2019 10:03:27 am

BTW, yes, its GREAT fun being a misinformed racist!! You idiot..

Dan
9/29/2019 12:02:01 pm

Here's the link. Cut and paste. Learn how to learn, little parrot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhFRGDyX48c&fbclid=IwAR0QlT0iLgMFmT8ZAFkwmSg8B12tl7tm7Mc7mZejj8OSB9NjztZBg5TZbR8

Michael Vecsey
4/8/2019 06:20:03 am

The fact you cab so causally say you are thinking of becoming a nazi proves how depraved you are. Your irish red herring proves how weak you must know your bs really is.

Sean
4/11/2019 09:39:17 am

You people hurt my brain with your idiocy... Hows THIS for a Red Herring... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocides_in_history

And FUCK YOU very much, for casually claiming the Irish Genocide was a Red Herring, your last name end in Stein by any chance?

Michael Vecsey
4/11/2019 10:28:39 am

Hate wiki all you like little guy. I told you to look at its references at the bottom of the page. Be a big boy and stop posting the dumb crap in your head

John
4/12/2019 02:02:13 pm

So you hate Wikipedia, then you use Wikipedia as a reference, then you insinuate the other guy is Jewish???

LMAO, now we see the type of people that are sucked in by the idiocy of Robert Sepehr. It is not an accident that Sepher sees blue eyed Aryans and swastikas everywhere while talking negatively about Jews and blacks.

Michael Vecsey
4/11/2019 10:26:21 am

Lol. Too dumb to look up what red herring means? No one denied it you loser. Its just utterly off topic here. It shows you are deeply confused. Just as you confuse "you are" with "your" in your previous post. No wonder you fall for robert s and his crappy research.

Sally
9/21/2019 08:06:39 pm

If Mr. Sepher's book was well-researched it would have included footnotes and citations. The red-flag is that the book was self-published by Atlantean Gardens, the same name as R. Sepher's website. Books that are significant and valuable are usually published by a reputable publishing company. Not all, mind you, but subsequent books usually do bet a book deal for the author, if he’s on the up-and-up.

Dan
9/29/2019 12:08:29 pm

Our world is closer to nuclear conflict than ever before. Our global economic system - fiat, debt-based currency and the derivatives bubble - will be overturned within moments, creating suffering unimaginable to us SYSTEMATICALLY MISINFORMED AS WE ARE. The people running this ship are beyond corrupt, beyond degenerate, beyond demonic. And it is about to run to ground, in spectacular fashion. But oh - peer review! The circle jerk of peer review will save us! Daddy authority!!! Respectability! The in-crowd!! Thank god for that...

Spartan Lock 117
1/23/2020 02:49:00 pm

What a snotty, churlish, banal and sarcastic little review more in keeping with a high school huff than an in depth examination.

The Bell Curve
3/21/2020 01:11:23 am

“...(except for outdated racist ideas about Cro-Magnon)”. I Stopped reading right there.

Boaz and the rest of (((them))) have obviously got you by the balls and by the brainstem, bud.

Next time perhaps leave supremely dubious terminology such as ‘racist’ out of your discussions.
It might improve your analysis... slightly.

I challenge you not to censor this.

By the way, I’m not even an admirer of Sepehr, just to be clear.

Bart Bartholomew
4/13/2020 11:37:13 am

Whatever you learned at school, none of it means its a benchmark truth. If anything , you should have learned that history is in canstant flux of discovery and refinement...
You fail to acknowledge that some actually dont work for univercities and are not paid to beguardians of your sacred knowledge which bars the history from being refined by new duscoveries, but instead standing guard to the dogma you were preached to and preach it yourself.
Go figure. Haters gonna hate

Lib
4/14/2020 07:57:29 pm

What "new discoveries"? Ancient Egyptians, Romans, Greeks, Sumerians, Israelis, Chinese, Mongolians, and whoever else weren't some group on now-extinct Germanics. End of. There's absolutely no evidence of any of this, no genetic or cultural. I've watched multiple videos by the nazi and he backs his claims up with nothing that could be considered credible. He makes as much sense has Ken Ham and his 100 million dollar Young Earth Creationist empire.

Greg
5/10/2020 04:27:16 pm

You are clearly jealous of him; and you are trying to steal, "Independents"

But somehow you've missed out on most of history. You're a professor? No wonder. You may get tools to regress

But you are a charlatan. I don't care what race or culture you are: but your little article is the product of a slave mentality.

The modern paradigms of most systems are lies: look at the medical system :D "Take a vaccine instead of medicine"

You need medicine. I hope you don't get vaccinated: but I am against genocide but sadly, I wouldn't care if we threw away a bunch of rusty TOOLS. Yeah, you're the tool in that metaphor.

Think for yourself. Grow a pair. You are a wanker and I don't entirely agree with Sepehr but he has more insight than a teacher (Those who can't do; teach!) Write your own book faggot. This entire article was based upon your inferiority bullshit. Shove your race card up your ass! I'm Black. We don't like people like you #Crips

Dolly
2/25/2021 04:46:06 am

I love that you said "#crips" like someone reading this would be like "oh wow, he MUST be black if he said that." Little louder than a dogwhistle but thank you for the laugh!

Unbiased and conscious link
7/2/2020 08:33:54 am

Here's an opposite point of view from a very qualified geneticist. The former Lloyd Pie who died (quiet suddenly from cancer) after disclosing secret information Robert could do with adding to his theories. I don’t believe RS will be took out for his angle on ancient history.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhFRGDyX48c&fbclid=IwAR0QlT0iLgMFmT8ZAFkwmSg8B12tl7tm7Mc7mZejj8OSB9NjztZBg5TZbR8

Unbiased and conscious link
7/2/2020 08:40:28 am

Lloyd pie link - https://youtu.be/3xcE0qDv5lw

Stephen
8/7/2020 11:28:04 pm

DNA in the past ten years has shown that there were separate species that interbred. The Out of Africa theory was a pharse and has completely been debunked by DNA. Caucasoid largely interbred originally with Neanderthal, Negroid with Homo Erectus.

Jonathan Sipper
8/15/2020 02:34:02 am

So what of the Morronos and the affiliation with Savi , claiming redemption through "sin" ? So how many of my Jewish brothers turned their backs on Adoni and started worshiping this "Government god" ? I enjoy these talks and every ones input! We all let our Esau out from time to time , once we remember it's not about us individuals but us as a whole system of living organisms. An just a lot of awesomeness!

Y'all wild
9/10/2020 09:04:29 pm

Of course this BLM shit we got now let's start an organization that's called white lives matter and let's see how long that flies smh

Mark Zemekis
9/7/2020 01:06:23 pm

The Out of Africa theory died a long time ago. It's embarrassing watching people still defend it.

Neanderthal-X
2/26/2021 07:38:42 pm

"In the 2010s, studies in population genetics uncovered evidence of interbreeding that occurred between H. sapiens and archaic humans in Eurasia, Oceania and Africa, indicating that modern population groups, while mostly derived from early H. sapiens, are to a lesser extent also descended from regional variants of archaic humans." - Wikipedia entry on "Recent African origin of modern humans"

The Out of Africa theory didn't die a long time ago, it was simply slightly modified.

Sepehr's book is bullshit. I'm tempted to say, that reading the comments here, one is liable to loose faith in humanity. But the internet and such topics tend to attract the idiots of humanity. Thankfully in the real world they're less common.

Y'all wild
9/10/2020 09:02:26 pm

I really think people get into these types of discussions because they are very unhappy, uncomfortable and are looking for somebody to persecute or in this case a witch to burn. Most of these people are the same people who wanna crawl up the president's ass and complain what his shit smells like every time CNN comes on. Of course I detest politics on the whole and the bipartisan system but that's something that took years of working on campaigns and then years of research to figure out. I know all these political types and they're legit obsessed like it might as well be crack cocaine the way they act

Alicia
9/23/2020 05:28:37 am

You may have tried to scare us away from buying this book, but ( at least in my case) you have done just the opposite.

Lanfeust
11/24/2020 04:12:35 am

You clearly don't know anything about what you're talking about, and don't give a fuck about science and true research.

A true scientist and anthropologist is someone who seeks the truth, not someone like you trying to diminish the work of another anthropologist simply because his views don't fit the forced systemic dogma.

In the first place, the "body of knowledge" pointing to an African origin of humanity always was tremendously retarded. What, just because you did some research in some places in Africa, and found ancient remains, that would mean we come from there ?

Too bad for you that since this retarded Out of Africa theory was invented, numerous studies and research has found even older remains in other parts of the world, like China or Greece, dismantling your bullshit right away.

See, science isn't about believing a dogma, like a fanatic religious slave, science is about research, and you can't do a lot of research on anything really if you're loaded with retarded dogma that has nothing to do with science and all to do with ideological agenda.

But one doesn't have to read your pathetic review very far to understand you're either an ignorant or an agent of the anti-white system.

"In the second chapter, Sepehr introduces the idea that "race" and "species" are equivalent and that human "races" are actually separate species. This isn't Sepehr's original thought, of course, but one handed down from the slavers and Nazis of the last centuries."

Not only the existence of human races and species is proven by science (but you would have to be, again, a retard to actually need scientific studies to prove something so obvious, if you need one, begin by meditating on the 19% of "ghost DNA" possessed by Africans that is impossible to identify according to recent studies), but this idea also doesn't come from slavers or nazis, peoples of every parts of the world have always divided humanity in different races/groups, and the first books featuring racial maps and analysis of human races are much older than national-socialists and have nothing to do with slavers. The National-Socialists simply did their own researches and improved what already existed before.

Ellen
11/24/2020 11:57:33 am

I was actually looking for a legit critique of Sepehr's work, but this ain't it.

Harte
3/13/2021 07:40:44 am

Sepehr may or may not be a complete idiot. Hard to tell - it depends on whether he actually believes the total crap he claims.

However, it's quite easy to see that his followers ARE certainly idiots.

Chris R Spencer
4/14/2021 09:18:50 am

Andy White. Now how about reviewing the writings of a real anthropologist with real credentials like USC professor Walter Lee Williams Jr.

Desi
7/10/2021 03:12:56 am

The moment you threw in the racism slur you revealed yourself to be an idiot. Because of your purile review I ordered Species with Amnesia and I bought Gods with Amnesia too. Envy is deadly.

Noel B Diotte
12/17/2021 01:52:36 pm

Sepehr plays a mean uke and does feed the ducks or sit at the beach in Santa Monica. And he is from LA. Perhaps, he'll write an original screenplay and film, about white supremacy and show the evil geniuses and worst culprits in history. The first few minutes of his music and feeding the ducks before the content begins and he usually inserts some other old video content. It's Entertainment, like the History Channel, not meant to be scientific. Some good content at times, better than Tik Tok and God knows there are too many cute cat videos on the web.

Luna
1/5/2022 08:53:41 pm

this is a really sad review left by a really sad, artificial man. I honestly feel really bad for people who are as dense as you my guy. your sense of perception is so low you couldn’t even comprehend half the points Robert made. too brainwashed by the UN funded education system. not everyone in this world is supposed to be able to understand what Robert is talking about, for we’re at a point now in history where majority of humans are way too physical and dense in their thinking that any truth sounds insane to them. it’s kinda funny actually when you’re on the other side watching people like you. someone so out of touch with who they are and where they come from. will push continuously disproven theories because the mainstream accepts it as fact. dumb.

Andrew Laurence
12/2/2022 07:53:06 am

What’s sad is that you could be so deluded and gullible as to accept the drivel of a charlatan like Sepehr. Have fun living in your racist conspiracist LARP.

A J Mitchell
12/1/2022 05:24:09 pm

I know plenty of educated people who believe what Robert S says, your just woke and your whole life a joke, anyone who thinks our history hasn't been fk'd with or democracy stolen is completely fkn retarded full fkn stop, I come from power, masonic family history i know, wake up sheeeeep, nothing wrong with disliking others get over yourself and grow so damn balls!! !!!!!

CV
11/21/2023 07:41:08 am

Only took 30 seconds to realize Andy has been heavily brainwashed and sees the world though a twisted woke lens..

Ignore these types, they're intellectually/morally/spiritually broken. You cannot reason with them.


Comments are closed.

    All views expressed in my blog posts are my own. The views of those that comment are their own. That's how it works.

    I reserve the right to take down comments that I deem to be defamatory or harassing. 

    Andy White

    Email me: [email protected]

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


    Picture

    Sick of the woo?  Want to help keep honest and open dialogue about pseudo-archaeology on the internet? Please consider contributing to Woo War Two.
    Picture

    Follow updates on posts related to giants on the Modern Mythology of Giants page on Facebook.

    Archives

    January 2024
    January 2023
    January 2022
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    March 2021
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    3D Models
    AAA
    Adena
    Afrocentrism
    Agent Based Modeling
    Agent-based Modeling
    Aircraft
    Alabama
    Aliens
    Ancient Artifact Preservation Society
    Androgynous Fish Gods
    ANTH 227
    ANTH 291
    ANTH 322
    Anthropology History
    Anunnaki
    Appalachia
    Archaeology
    Ardipithecus
    Art
    Atlantis
    Australia
    Australopithecines
    Aviation History
    Bigfoot
    Birds
    Boas
    Book Of Mormon
    Broad River Archaeological Field School
    Bronze Age
    Caribou
    Carolina Bays
    Ceramics
    China
    Clovis
    Complexity
    Copper Culture
    Cotton Mather
    COVID-19
    Creationism
    Croatia
    Crow
    Demography
    Denisovans
    Diffusionism
    DINAA
    Dinosaurs
    Dirt Dance Floor
    Double Rows Of Teeth
    Dragonflies
    Early Archaic
    Early Woodland
    Earthworks
    Eastern Woodlands
    Eastern Woodlands Household Archaeology Data Project
    Education
    Egypt
    Europe
    Evolution
    Ewhadp
    Fake Hercules Swords
    Fetal Head Molding
    Field School
    Film
    Florida
    Forbidden Archaeology
    Forbidden History
    Four Field Anthropology
    Four-field Anthropology
    France
    Genetics
    Genus Homo
    Geology
    Geometry
    Geophysics
    Georgia
    Giants
    Giants Of Olden Times
    Gigantism
    Gigantopithecus
    Graham Hancock
    Grand Valley State
    Great Lakes
    Hollow Earth
    Homo Erectus
    Hunter Gatherers
    Hunter-gatherers
    Illinois
    India
    Indiana
    Indonesia
    Iowa
    Iraq
    Israel
    Jim Vieira
    Jobs
    Kensington Rune Stone
    Kentucky
    Kirk Project
    Late Archaic
    Lemuria
    Lithic Raw Materials
    Lithics
    Lizard Man
    Lomekwi
    Lost Continents
    Mack
    Mammoths
    Mastodons
    Maya
    Megafauna
    Megaliths
    Mesolithic
    Michigan
    Middle Archaic
    Middle Pleistocene
    Middle Woodland
    Midwest
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Mississippian
    Missouri
    Modeling
    Morphometric
    Mound Builder Myth
    Mu
    Music
    Nazis
    Neandertals
    Near East
    Nephilim
    Nevada
    New Mexico
    Newspapers
    New York
    North Carolina
    Oahspe
    Oak Island
    Obstetrics
    Ohio
    Ohio Valley
    Oldowan
    Olmec
    Open Data
    Paleoindian
    Paleolithic
    Pilumgate
    Pleistocene
    Pliocene
    Pre Clovis
    Pre-Clovis
    Prehistoric Families
    Pseudo Science
    Pseudo-science
    Radiocarbon
    Reality Check
    Rome
    Russia
    SAA
    Sardinia
    SCIAA
    Science
    Scientific Racism
    Sculpture
    SEAC
    Search For The Lost Giants
    Sexual Dimorphism
    Sitchin
    Social Complexity
    Social Networks
    Solutrean Hypothesis
    South Africa
    South America
    South Carolina
    Southeast
    Stone Holes
    Subsistence
    Swordgate
    Teaching
    Technology
    Teeth
    Television
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Topper
    Travel
    Travel Diaries
    Vaccines
    Washington
    Whatzit
    White Supremacists
    Wisconsin
    Woo War Two
    World War I
    World War II
    Writing
    Younger Dryas

    RSS Feed

    Picture
Proudly powered by Weebly