Andy White Anthropology
  • Home
  • Research Interests
    • Complexity Science
    • Prehistoric Social Networks
    • Eastern Woodlands Prehistory
    • Ancient Giants
  • Blog
  • Work in Progress
    • The Kirk Project >
      • Kirk 3D Models list
      • Kirk 3D Models embedded
      • Kirk 2D images >
        • Indiana
        • Kentucky
        • Michigan
        • Ontario
      • Kirk Project Datasets
    • Computational Modeling >
      • FN3D_V3
    • Radiocarbon Compilation
    • Fake Hercules Swords
    • Wild Carolina >
      • Plants >
        • Mosses
        • Ferns
        • Conifers
        • Flowering Plants >
          • Grasses
          • Trees
          • Other Flowering Plants
      • Animals >
        • Birds
        • Mammals
        • Crustaceans
        • Insects
        • Arachnids
        • Millipedes and Centipedes
        • Reptiles and Amphibians
      • Fungi
  • Annotated Publications
    • Journal Articles
    • Technical Reports
    • Doctoral Dissertation
  • Bibliography
  • Data

A New Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt Comparison of the Hercules-Hilted Swords

1/14/2016

21 Comments

 
Peter Geuzen has updated his previous image showing the hilts of the four known brass/bronze swords (plus the Design Toscano sword) to include two additional swords that surfaced yesterday.  So now that's six copper alloy sword that we know about (presuming that the France sword is really bronze alloy and not just painted with fake patina).  

No, they're not plastic, or "stone painted bronze," or Photoshopped . . . these are real items that appear to be more-or-less identical to the alleged "Roman sword" from Nova Scotia.  The "lost Roman legion" explanation has a really difficult time dealing with the fact that more and more of these things keep showing up. My 19th century tourist souvenir hypothesis, however, accounts for all the facts (and all the swords) that we currently have in front of us. My hypothesis has no trouble dealing with the appearance of additional swords, and, actually the more swords the better!  "Roman swords" seem to be a growth industry these days!  

​The appearance of more and more swords is not so good for the alternative hypothesis, however.

​Here is a link to Geuzen's image.

View post on imgur.com
My $50 reward stands: determine the origin of the bronze/brass swords, reap the glory.
21 Comments
James Lawrence
1/14/2016 01:05:58 pm

$50 may not be Powerball size...but I'll take it. Especially when $50 U.S. is like a bazillion dollars Canadian right now.

Reply
Neil
1/14/2016 01:57:24 pm

...how does the Design Toscana (a present-day vendor of...um...'cheesy' 'works of art' & reproductions) item fit with "19th Century Souvenir" hypothesis..?

Reply
Andy White
1/14/2016 02:04:48 pm

I think the DT swords (currently being produced in cast iron) are a second generation, based on copying one of an earlier generation of copper alloy souvenirs. That's a hypothesis, anyway.

Reply
Peter Geuzen
1/14/2016 06:07:13 pm

Confirmed in the media that the alleged Oak Island sword would never have been covered by protective tresure legislation when in was supposedly found in the 1940s. JHPs ranting of the fearful fisherman also worried about fishing regulations has also been proven to be bunk because there were no regs in place for scallop fishing at the time - thanks to James Lawrence for confirming this as well as previously confirming the treasure regs not applying.

http://thechronicleherald.ca/novascotia/1333458-oak-island-sword-gets-province%E2%80%99s-attention
http://www.metronews.ca/news/halifax/2016/01/14/province-interested-in-supposed-roman-sword-on-oak-island.html

Read all the comments:

https://www.facebook.com/notes/hutton-pulitzer/what-it-takes-to-verify-artifacts-and-history-and-how-it-can-kick-a-mans-butt-wh/443055059231156#

Reply
Andy White
1/14/2016 06:16:33 pm

It doesn't appear that I have access to that Facebook page. Another shocking development!

Reply
James Lawrence
1/14/2016 06:32:19 pm

My favourite line from JHP on that string was "Now, WHY do I happen to know these things and expert comment on them? I wrote the domestic and international law text and education book on treasure law. State by state, country by country."

Wow - state by state and country by country...yet he posts a link to U.S. Federal scalloping laws to 'school me' on what applies to Nova Scotian (i.e. Canadian) waters.

Reply
Trevor Kenchington
1/14/2016 06:46:01 pm

The "sword" that isn't clearly also isn't Roman and very probably hasn't been under salt water for long enough to get more than damp. I'm very glad to see so many people taking the time to expose the ludicrous claims for what they are.

However, before anyone claims to have yet another reason to dismiss fanciful nonsense:

Nova Scotia's Special Places Protection Act came into effect in the mid-1980s. It did not apply when we excavated a wreck in 1981-83 but did (or was purported to) when I carried out my next archaeological fieldwork in about 1987-89 -- "purported" because it has always been doubtful whether Nova Scotian legislation (as distinct from Canadian federal law) applies beyond the tidemark. Still, there is a long history of other legislation concerning items legally deemed "wreck", which in this part of the world are still subject to the provisions of the Canada Shipping Act. A fisherman who found something valuable should have reported it to the Receiver of Wreck and, if he chose not to, had good reason to keep quiet. Indeed, by the 1970s the federal government had an Underwater Archaeology Unit and was taking a more active interest in the archaeological potential on the seabed. One unfortunate Newfoundland SCUBA diver had the very, very rare privilege of finding a mariner's astrolabe. Word got out and, one night, two large police officers showed up at his house, demanding that he hand it over.

Pulitzer's nonsense is not more nonsensical because he has a half-understood tale of why somebody chose not to announce the find of a sword-like object.

(Incidentally: the 1981-83 excavation mentioned above gave rise to the "1754" date which Pulitzer has declared is not the date of his "Roman" wreck. "My" wreck probably wasn't lost in '54, despite what the Nova Scotia Museum is likely to tell you, but it was certainly built within 100 years of the mid-18th Century. I'm not quite incompetent enough to confuse circa 100AD mortice-and-tenon Mediterranean ship construction with the circa 1750 New England plank-on-frame version!)

Reply
Trevor Kenchington
1/14/2016 06:58:12 pm

Missed one sentence in that last post: I have no reason to think that Pulitzer's claimed wreck is the same one that we excavated near 35 years ago. It's just odd that he should have quoted the date that is sometimes attached to "my" site.

Jonathan Feinstein
1/15/2016 04:19:55 am

Judging strictly by photos can be misleading, but it looks to me as though the known swords fall into at least two different families of castings as evidenced by the way the lion skin is wrapped around the figure's waist. on some, like the Nova Scotia and Florida swords, the line formed by the lion skin forms a sort of rounded "V" shape, whereas in the California, French (and possibly Spanish) swords the skin forms a flat, nearly straight line along his waist for a short way. It is a minor detail, but a telling one in that at least some of these are copies. Yes, we knew that the Design Toscano Swords are copies, even the manufacturer says that, but I meant that whatever the original turns out to have been, it has been copied more than once.

More concerning to me, though, is the nature of the figure on the hilt. This is not a common pose for Hercules. Most ancient pieces I could find have him holding his club in only one hand or else resting it on the ground or his shoulder. It is almost as though one of his divine attributes to be depicted was the strength to use it single handedly. Most double-handed poses I can find seem to be representations from the Renaissance (but as this is not my field of expertise, I may not have sufficient samples to judge that by).

I cannot help but suspect that the Hercules figure here might not have originated as a sword hilt, but instead was a bit of vertical ornamentation on something else (a piece of furniture, perhaps?). The guesses of a19th Century origin of these swords sound reasonable to me since that was a period in which all sorts of odd bits of Greco-Roman art was incorporated into previously unrelated objects.
Whether my guesses turn out to be right or wrong, though, I do hope someone finds where these swords came from. It seems odd we should be finding so many of them and yet not have any clear idea of their origin.

One more thing... I was unaware that the Romans made any gladii (regardless of whether they were intended to be fought with or not) out of bronze or any copper alloy. I had learned they were mostly either iron or low carbon steel. I could understand if someone chose to make a special series of votive objects with cast-on bronze hilts, but I would have thought they would use iron/steel blades. It is not like they were in short supply, every soldier had one (I think) and iron was certainly less expensive than bronze.

FTR, however, sometime in an earlier comment or post, someone wondered at how dull these blades are. If they are as young as we all seem to think, then that also argues they were merely made as decorative objects recently, but if they are old... well, my experience with Roman period weaponry is slim at best, but I have studied Middle Eastern Bronze Age weapons, and many of them no longer have much of an edge either. Many are mostly blade-shaped masses of verdigris corrosion perhaps with some of the original metal still inside. The basic shape of the blade remains, but the this, sharp edges, corroded off long ago.

Reply
James Lawrence
1/15/2016 06:23:15 am

Just a couple of things related to swordgate you may find interesting:

Firstly, I emailed a woman in Naples (Jeannette Vlietstra of http://pompeiitours.nl/en/ ) who specializes in (paid) guided tours of Naples, Pompeii and Herculaneum points of interest (including the Naples National Museum). It was reasonable to assume that someone who provides such tours would have a high probability of seeing this sword in Naples at some point (it is after all fairly distinct). I sent pic's and a brief background that such a sword was found in Nova Scotia and claims were made a similar one resided in Naples.

Her response (this morning) was: "Hi James, i've never seen this sword before. It is certainly NOT exposed in the archeological museum of Naples, in this moment. Even during the special exhibition about the gladiators with swords and shields, I don't remember I've seen this special sword with the little man ( Hercules?) on the top. I'm sorry I can't help u further.
Goodluck"

Second, I found the following site online:
https://archive.org/details/illustratedguide00museiala
There are a number of (old) illustrated guides here for the National Museum in Naples, where you can flip through annual catalogues of the museum contents and images. Thus far, I have been unable to locate any picture or inventory reference to such a sword - but I have not gone through all yet...so encourage others to do so if you wish and see what (if anything) you may come up with.I believe Pompeii was discovered in late 18th century, so I would think any sword found there (and residing in Naples museum) should be on the inventory list. In fact it seems the museum specialized more so in painting and stone/bronze statues - with only a couple of minor gladiator items (helmets) to be found. No swords or edged weapons to speak of.

Reply
Michael
1/15/2016 08:52:56 am

Cool!! Thank you for sharing. I downloaded the PDF and I went through it for 45 minutes, but no luck in finding it.

Reply
Mike Jones
1/15/2016 07:22:19 am

In looking at the pictures, it is OBVIOUS that the shiny knees on the "Oak Island" sword are bare brass, not gold. As Andy and others have pointed out, the highest relief parts of a figure get more contact with your hand and the patina is "polished" off by friction. If the figure had been gold plated, the lower parts and crevasses would retain the plating, not the higher parts. Also, gold doesn't tarnish. That's the whole point of gold plating. The fact the Treasure Commander cannot tell gold from brass is telling and, in my opinion, HILARIOUS!

Reply
ghettohillbilly1
1/16/2016 07:58:17 am

agreed, he also doesnt realize frank magazine is more of a tabloid, and them hanging up on him multple times is the icing on the cake Hutton IS the curse of hoax island

Reply
Benjamin
1/15/2016 10:36:19 am

I know the origin of the sword, but I doubt I can prove it sufficiently to earn your $50.

I did UNB's study abroad to Pompeii and Herculaneum in 2005. I bought that exact sword at a mobile gift shop for 50euros outside old Pompeii.

Unfortunately, I don't have any photographs of buying the sword nor can I pose with it right now (it's stored at my family's in Halifax while I'm in Fredericton), but I do have a 2008 photo of the sword hanging in the background on my college bedroom wall. I am sending it to your e-mail promptly.


Cheers!
Benjamin

Reply
Peter Geuzen
1/15/2016 11:24:19 am

A new Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt-to-Hilt Comparison could be on the way.

You could also post the pic to http://imgur.com/ and then put the link in another post. No account needed, just upload and get the link.

Reply
ghettohillbilly1
1/16/2016 04:37:48 am

you sure its still there, maybe its your sword on the show lol

Reply
Mike
1/17/2016 09:01:46 am

Anyone else on the trip buy the same sword?

Reply
Andy White
1/17/2016 09:05:02 am

Just FYI for anyone reading this that doesn't know: a photo of Benjamin's sword is in this post:

http://www.andywhiteanthropology.com/blog/hercules-hilted-swords-for-sale-in-italy-two-data-points

Hopefully we can get a better image at some point.

Reply
ghettohillbilly1
1/17/2016 02:18:17 pm

have you considered letting the chronicle herald know you have the same sword? I'm sure they'd love to do an interview and/or take some pics

Reply
Big Fred
1/15/2016 06:02:48 pm

Does anyone have a discount coupon code for this Ancient Sculpture Gallery place? $59.00 seems a bit steep. (But I don't want to be the last person to own one of these.)
https://www.ancientsculpturegallery.com/gladiator-sword-from-pompeii-museum-replica.html

Reply
Killbuck
1/18/2016 08:54:12 am

Design Toscano has them on sale right now for 19 bucks. There's your discount.

That website only suggests it's like one from Pompeii, but does not specify it. The ancientsculpturegalley.com page specifically states the original in in the naples Museum:

"Gladiator Sword from Pompeii. Foundry cast iron replica from the Naples Museum. Paying homage to the craftsmanship and technique of metalsmiths in the Roman Empire, our exclusive museum replica is a rough iron foundry casting like those found in Pompeii. This remarkably heavyweight replica boasts characteristic details, and makes a handsome gift for yourself or anyone who enjoys Roman history or artifacts."

It's a lot of cut and paste from the DT site, but makes a specific attribution to an original, which according to the website of that museum, no such sword is cataloged.

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    All views expressed in my blog posts are my own. The views of those that comment are their own. That's how it works.

    I reserve the right to take down comments that I deem to be defamatory or harassing. 

    Andy White

    Follow me on Twitter: @Andrew_A_White

    Email me: andy.white.zpm@gmail.com

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


    Picture

    Sick of the woo?  Want to help keep honest and open dialogue about pseudo-archaeology on the internet? Please consider contributing to Woo War Two.
    Picture

    Follow updates on posts related to giants on the Modern Mythology of Giants page on Facebook.

    Archives

    January 2023
    January 2022
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    March 2021
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    3D Models
    AAA
    Adena
    Afrocentrism
    Agent Based Modeling
    Agent-based Modeling
    Aircraft
    Alabama
    Aliens
    Ancient Artifact Preservation Society
    Androgynous Fish Gods
    ANTH 227
    ANTH 291
    ANTH 322
    Anthropology History
    Anunnaki
    Appalachia
    Archaeology
    Ardipithecus
    Art
    Atlantis
    Australia
    Australopithecines
    Aviation History
    Bigfoot
    Birds
    Boas
    Book Of Mormon
    Broad River Archaeological Field School
    Bronze Age
    Caribou
    Carolina Bays
    Ceramics
    China
    Clovis
    Complexity
    Copper Culture
    Cotton Mather
    COVID-19
    Creationism
    Croatia
    Crow
    Demography
    Denisovans
    Diffusionism
    DINAA
    Dinosaurs
    Dirt Dance Floor
    Double Rows Of Teeth
    Dragonflies
    Early Archaic
    Early Woodland
    Earthworks
    Eastern Woodlands
    Eastern Woodlands Household Archaeology Data Project
    Education
    Egypt
    Europe
    Evolution
    Ewhadp
    Fake Hercules Swords
    Fetal Head Molding
    Field School
    Film
    Florida
    Forbidden Archaeology
    Forbidden History
    Four Field Anthropology
    Four-field Anthropology
    France
    Genetics
    Genus Homo
    Geology
    Geometry
    Geophysics
    Georgia
    Giants
    Giants Of Olden Times
    Gigantism
    Gigantopithecus
    Graham Hancock
    Grand Valley State
    Great Lakes
    Hollow Earth
    Homo Erectus
    Hunter Gatherers
    Hunter-gatherers
    Illinois
    India
    Indiana
    Indonesia
    Iowa
    Iraq
    Israel
    Jim Vieira
    Jobs
    Kensington Rune Stone
    Kentucky
    Kirk Project
    Late Archaic
    Lemuria
    Lithic Raw Materials
    Lithics
    Lizard Man
    Lomekwi
    Lost Continents
    Mack
    Mammoths
    Mastodons
    Maya
    Megafauna
    Megaliths
    Mesolithic
    Michigan
    Middle Archaic
    Middle Pleistocene
    Middle Woodland
    Midwest
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Mississippian
    Missouri
    Modeling
    Morphometric
    Mound Builder Myth
    Mu
    Music
    Nazis
    Neandertals
    Near East
    Nephilim
    Nevada
    New Mexico
    Newspapers
    New York
    North Carolina
    Oahspe
    Oak Island
    Obstetrics
    Ohio
    Ohio Valley
    Oldowan
    Olmec
    Open Data
    Paleoindian
    Paleolithic
    Pilumgate
    Pleistocene
    Pliocene
    Pre Clovis
    Pre-Clovis
    Prehistoric Families
    Pseudo Science
    Pseudo-science
    Radiocarbon
    Reality Check
    Rome
    Russia
    SAA
    Sardinia
    SCIAA
    Science
    Scientific Racism
    Sculpture
    SEAC
    Search For The Lost Giants
    Sexual Dimorphism
    Sitchin
    Social Complexity
    Social Networks
    Solutrean Hypothesis
    South Africa
    South America
    South Carolina
    Southeast
    Stone Holes
    Subsistence
    Swordgate
    Teaching
    Technology
    Teeth
    Television
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Topper
    Travel
    Travel Diaries
    Vaccines
    Washington
    Whatzit
    White Supremacists
    Wisconsin
    Woo War Two
    World War I
    World War II
    Writing
    Younger Dryas

    RSS Feed

    Picture
Proudly powered by Weebly